By P C, Drummond Island, MI on Monday, December 8, 2003 - 11:54 am:
Dave of Mohawk --
Agree 100% with your question:where's the mystery?
Seems to me the REAL mystery would be about any ship that gets THROUGH one of those autumn storms. All the talk about "mystery" and "cover-up" is hogwash. All one needs to do is to stand on the beach during one of those November storms, just about anywhere around the upper Lakes,and watch its power. The breakers actually shake the ground you're standing on, even if you're standing on bedrock. Y'all need to read Frederick Stonehouse's book abot the sinking of FITZGERALD. There are a lot of pieces of information to consider. I agree with Stonehouse -- FITZGERALD probably sank because of her damaged hatch coamings. The reports from ANDERSON's log & crew vis-a-vis FITZ's passage ove the shoal are not coherent. Nothing against ANDERSON, but they didn't know FITZGERALD was about to sink. Remember, it was Anderson who first reported that FITZGERALD was missing, maybe no more that moments after the fact. Also agree with all who have mentioned that the FITZ wreck was not the only wreck that has happened in modern times.
By WOLFF on Monday, May 9, 2005 - 08:19 pm:
I wish to encourage everyone to listen to my song titled "Shove On Fitzgerald" which is a tribute to the crew of the Edmund Fitzgerald. You can find a sample of this song at:
http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/wolffmusic
I hope you all enjoy it.