By Edward, MN Yooper on Monday, May 16, 2005 - 04:49 am:
Admiral Rickover conducted an in-depth investigation of the sinking of the Maine six or seven years prior to his retirement, after well over half a century in service to the Navy and many honors under his belt. The results were published by the Department of the Navy. There is still debate on the issue in some quarters, despite the exhaustive study of the forensic evidence of the ship, the many accounts of Spanish soldiers rushing to help the American sailors in the aftermath, the fact that Spain had no interest in provoking a losing war with the United States, the widespread incidence of coal-bunker fires on other naval ships during the same time period, etc.
At the time, the justification for the war was wrapped in pieties and fueled by cynical maneuvering of politicians and rampant "yellow journalism", all at the expense of the citizenry and their family members who died in uniform. The call-to-arms provoked by the alleged Spanish sinking of the Maine incited good, reasonable people to drop their guard and get behind a cause that didn't take their interests into account in the least, and there were fatal consequences for many.
The supposed concern on the part of politicians for the Cubans who were "under the boot" of the occupying Spaniards was later shown to be a smokescreen for the emerging imperial ambitions of the time. Why else would elected officials make speeches in defense of preserving the lives and freedom of a relative handful of downtrodden Cubans - a noble cause, to be sure - but then move forward with policies that directly resulted in the death of hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians in the Philippines, not to mention enlisted men on all sides, by the time the conflict ended?
The simple answer is that the lives of the soldiers, sailors, and innumerable civilians were secondary and expendable, that it was more important to expand the imperial reach of U.S. business and financial interests of the time than it was to observe the words of the sixth commandment, "Thou shalt not kill". (Not to mention the Golden Rule, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you", for those who follow such things.) Those thirteen brave young men from Calumet, who never returned from the conflict, deserved better. They deserved long lives. We should never forget the sacrifice they made, nor the reasons why they were compelled to make it.
I located a quote from Admiral Rickover's conclusion to his study:
"In the modern technological age, the battle cry 'Remember the Maine!' should have a special meaning for us. With the vastness of our government and the difficulty of controlling it, we must make sure that those in 'high places' do not, without most careful consideration of the consequences, exert our prestige and might. Such uses of our power may result in serious international actions at great cost in lives and money - injurious to the interests and standing of the United States."
By maija on Monday, May 16, 2005 - 07:21 am:
profound words, Edward.
By bob brown, AL on Monday, May 16, 2005 - 07:51 am:
At one stage, President Roosevelt is reported to have said, "It is a small war, but it's the only one we have".
This was after the destruction of the Spanish navy ...i.e. "You may fire when ready, Gridley."
By Sherry, Gulfport MS on Friday, May 20, 2005 - 01:54 am:
Notice that everyone is wearing a hat? How fashionable as compared to today!